Lies in California

Ashley Thorne

On Friday, NAS wrote about a podcast of a public presentation given by UC Berkeley Chancellor Robert Birgeneau. In his speech, the chancellor repeatedly referred to proportional decreases in Caucasian males as “a triumph” and as “significant progress.” He called the large percentage of white male executives “one of our great challenges, which we’re working on very hard.”

Apparently, that hard work is paying off...literally. At Minding the Campus, John Ellis has an incisive article about deceptions propagated by Chancellor Birgeneau in the case of Linda Williams. With the institution in a budget crisis, university employees who retired voluntarily were offered a severance pay incentive. Linda Williams transferred from her position as Associate President at the University of California System headquarters to a position as Associate Chancellor at UC Berkeley. As John Ellis puts it, “She sought severance pay though she had never been severed.”

After she applied for the pay, Chancellor Birgeneau backed her up, and a myriad of lies were concocted to falsely represent that Williams had applied for severance before she was placed in her new position. Professor Ellis uncovers the dishonesty and how Birgeneau framed investigation into the matter as racial harassment “creating a chilling climate for all African Americans on campus.”

Professor Ellis concludes by returning to the academy’s mission: the pursuit of Veritas:

Whether in the classroom or in research, knowledge is only knowledge if it’s based in truth. One lesson of this story is that the concern with diversity must never trump the academy’s core value, Veritas. A university that stops caring about truth will soon be of no use to anyone, minorities included. When a great university is led by someone who misleads seemingly without compunction, contrition, or consequences, it is sick at its core.

To read the whole article at Minding the Campus, click here.

  • Share

Most Commented

December 16, 2025

1.

DOJ Does Away with Disparate Impact Theory

Disparate impact theory is on the Trump administration’s chopping block, signaling a move away from discriminatory government policy practices....

March 3, 2026

2.

The Ayatollah’s Friends are on Your Campus

The U.S. strike on Iran and the foreign funding shaping how universities respond to it....

March 11, 2026

3.

Bad Faith Noncompliance: Virginia Schools Flout Supreme Court and Trump with DEI ‘Rebrand’

Trump’s EOs and the Supreme Court make DEI illegal—but colleges keep rebranding it to dodge the law....

Most Read

May 15, 2015

1.

Where Did We Get the Idea That Only White People Can Be Racist?

A look at the double standard that has arisen regarding racism, illustrated recently by the reaction to a black professor's biased comments on Twitter....

February 21, 2014

2.

Taking Care

Is art worth dying for? The Monuments Men considers the value of good art and its purpose in preserving a cultural heritage....

October 17, 2018

3.

Hamilton: An American Musical - Its National Influence as Art

William Young finds much to praise in the hit musical....