He Never Read von Mises

Mitchell Langbert

  • Article
  • March 15, 2010
Communist countries like Russia have developed with extraordinary speed in the past decades entirely by means of public enterprise.  In fact, by our index of the rate of economic growth, i.e., electricity produced (or consumed), Russia is now developing at a considerably faster rate than the United States...The regression coefficient for the U.S.S.R. (.05) represents a considerably faster growth rate than for the U.S. (.03), which means that Russia should reach the present level of U.S. development by 1967 and surpass it by 1990.  Can it be that public enterprise is always as inefficient and lacking in drive and practical imagination as pictured?

---David C. McClelland, The Achieving Society, 1961, p. 293. Academics' doctrinaire acceptance of Oskar Lange's defense of socialist marginalism and Clark Kerr's claim that convergence was inevitable along with rejection of Ludwig von Mises's and Friedrich von Hayek's arguments for the impossibility of socialist planning are reflected in McClelland's extrapolation.   The Soviet Union completely disintegrated in 1989, one year before McClelland's prediction of  its surpassing the U.S.  Although von Mises and Hayek were right and Lange, Kerr and McClelland were wrong all along, von Mises could not find a paying job at an American university.   Several donors covered his salary while he taught at NYU. So much for the claim that academic dogmatism began with the New Left and the 1960s.   The even more amazing footnote is that now that the Soviet Union has fallen, American academics argue for socialism as aggressively as ever.

  • Share

Most Commented

March 3, 2026

1.

The Ayatollah’s Friends are on Your Campus

The U.S. strike on Iran and the foreign funding shaping how universities respond to it....

March 11, 2026

2.

Bad Faith Noncompliance: Virginia Schools Flout Supreme Court and Trump with DEI ‘Rebrand’

Trump’s EOs and the Supreme Court make DEI illegal—but colleges keep rebranding it to dodge the law....

January 27, 2026

3.

Losing the West

As Western civilization courses vanish from higher education, so too are history professors, to the detriment of our civilization....

Most Read

May 15, 2015

1.

Where Did We Get the Idea That Only White People Can Be Racist?

A look at the double standard that has arisen regarding racism, illustrated recently by the reaction to a black professor's biased comments on Twitter....

February 21, 2014

2.

Taking Care

Is art worth dying for? The Monuments Men considers the value of good art and its purpose in preserving a cultural heritage....

October 17, 2018

3.

Hamilton: An American Musical - Its National Influence as Art

William Young finds much to praise in the hit musical....