Fisher Case Generates Wide Press Coverage, Reactions

Glenn Ricketts

Not surprisingly, the US Supreme Court's decision earlier this week to grant certiorari in the case of Fisher v. University of Texas has generated wide coverage and commentary in the academic press;  you can read CHE's account here and its equivalent at IHE here.  

An additional and potentially signifiacnt development has come to light since yesterday as well: Justice Elena Kagan has recused herself from the case  A former dean of Harvard Law School, Kagan also served as Solicitor General of the United States from March 2009 until she was apppointed to the Supreme Court by President Obama in 2010.  As Solicitor General, she had worked on the Fisher case to prepare a defense of race-based admissions, and would likely have been a supporter of the Texas "diversity" policies currently under legal challenge.

It's worth reading the comments threads to both articles, because the defenders of racial preferences seem particulalry shrill and frantic, with familiar remarks about reverting to pre-Brown v. Board of Education standards, etc., etc.  You get the sense that they're worried.  On the other hand, the critics are articulate and outspoken in ways that you didn't see too frequently in academic venues until recently.

It's impossible to anticipate what the Court will end up deciding, but reading these pieces gives you the sense that there's been a significant shift in the wind.  We hope that's true, as noted here yesterday.

 

 

  • Share

Most Commented

December 16, 2025

1.

DOJ Does Away with Disparate Impact Theory

Disparate impact theory is on the Trump administration’s chopping block, signaling a move away from discriminatory government policy practices....

March 3, 2026

2.

The Ayatollah’s Friends are on Your Campus

The U.S. strike on Iran and the foreign funding shaping how universities respond to it....

March 11, 2026

3.

Bad Faith Noncompliance: Virginia Schools Flout Supreme Court and Trump with DEI ‘Rebrand’

Trump’s EOs and the Supreme Court make DEI illegal—but colleges keep rebranding it to dodge the law....

Most Read

May 15, 2015

1.

Where Did We Get the Idea That Only White People Can Be Racist?

A look at the double standard that has arisen regarding racism, illustrated recently by the reaction to a black professor's biased comments on Twitter....

February 21, 2014

2.

Taking Care

Is art worth dying for? The Monuments Men considers the value of good art and its purpose in preserving a cultural heritage....

October 17, 2018

3.

Hamilton: An American Musical - Its National Influence as Art

William Young finds much to praise in the hit musical....